Forums > Free for AllPage 1 2by: *Wicked Mama*

My Sister's Keeper *Spoiler*

posted 18th Nov
Okay so for people who have read both the book and movie, I really need something cleared up for me. I heard in the movie the wrong sister dies. Is that true? And if so, what happens to kill the other sister? I am thoroughly confused right now.

Either way, that movie was fucking sad all the way through. I have a headache from crying.
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
I never read that book, but that was not a smart move to watch that movie while I was still preggo....I bawled the whole freaking movie and then worried that my baby would come out with cancer  
Idk if I could ever be that strong of a mama!
quote
I have 1 child & live in Mandeville, Louisiana
posted 18th Nov
Quoting Beezy ♥:“ I never read that book, but that was not a smart move to watch that movie while I was still preggo....I ... [snip!] ... freaking movie and then worried that my baby would come out with cancer   Idk if I could ever be that strong of a mama!”

I'm not even pregnant and I got all tore up. It broke my heart.
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
Quoting *Wicked Mama*:“ Okay so for people who have read both the book and movie, I really need something cleared up for me. ... [snip!] ... I am thoroughly confused right now. Either way, that movie was fucking sad all the way through. I have a headache from crying.”

FUCK THE MOVIE!
the book was so much better.
anna was supposed to die at the end and kate got better
quote
I'm due October 9th & live in Denton, Texas
posted 18th Nov
In the book, (I forget names) the one who was not receiving the transplant dies and the sister needing it, gets it. The sister who dies, dies in a car accident.
quote
I have 1 child & 2 angel babies & live in Louisiana
posted 18th Nov
Quoting L♥vey:“ In the book, (I forget names) the one who was not receiving the transplant dies and the sister needing it, gets it. The sister who dies, dies in a car accident.”
See, I had a feeling that's what actually happens in the book. That's CRAZY. Is the book better than the movie? I don't plan on reading it. That's intense.
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
Wait so what happens in the movie? They switch it so the one with cancer dies? Thats lame. I've only read the book and the younger sister dies in a car accident...
quote
I'm due July 10th (a girl), have 2 angel babies & live in Laguna Beach, California
posted 18th Nov
Quoting -MEAGHAN- [bebe please?]:“ FUCK THE MOVIE! the book was so much better. anna was supposed to die at the end and kate got better”

That sounds so mean lol
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
You should put a ***spoiler*** in the title. Not lots of people know that something happens to someone   Bummer
quote
I'm TTC since January '98 & live in American Fork, Utah
posted 18th Nov
Quoting TTC a BabyBumpBelly:“ You should put a ***spoiler*** in the title. Not lots of people know that something happens to someone   Bummer”

Sorry...I didn't really think it would end up being a spoiler. I'll fix it.
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
Quoting L♥vey:“ In the book, (I forget names) the one who was not receiving the transplant dies and the sister needing it, gets it. The sister who dies, dies in a car accident.”


Wow, that is so depressing.
I mean great that the one with cancer got better, but that sucks for the other sister. That poor mother, jeebus!!!
quote
I have 1 child & live in Mandeville, Louisiana
posted 18th Nov
Quoting *Wicked Mama*:“ That sounds so mean lol”

the story is pointless without anna dying.
IMO
it is so sad but if they both live at the end it was pretty much anti climatic
quote
I'm due October 9th & live in Denton, Texas
posted 18th Nov
I'm just curious at how vastly different it is then. For instance, did the sick sister WANT to die or WANT the transplant? It's so depressing but now I am starting to want to read the book.
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
Quoting -MEAGHAN- [bebe please?]:“ the story is pointless without anna dying. IMO it is so sad but if they both live at the end it was pretty much anti climatic”
They didn't both live in the movie, though.
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Washington
posted 18th Nov
Quoting *Wicked Mama*:“ I'm just curious at how vastly different it is then. For instance, did the sick sister WANT to die or WANT the transplant? It's so depressing but now I am starting to want to read the book.”
The sick sister wanted her sister to live her life and not be there just to make her better...does that make sense?
quote
I have 1 child & 1 angel baby & live in Florida
nextpost reply



who's online

There are 1901 people online826 members & 1075 guestssee all 826 members
 
alllatest topics
Love me some Em postedPink/Black Tankini. Super cute!!!1 min ago
whitney ♥ ainsley postedWhat size diapers (PWT)2 min ago
Ryan & Casey's mommy!!! postedTongue tied?2 min ago
ItsMeJeni postedvideo of my little girl LOLing...2 min ago
Kennith's Mama ♥ postedrelationships- leave it alone, or say something.2 min ago
Mia likes white noise postedlate pp period but not pregnant - ?2 min ago
TheAtomicSponge postedi NEED suggestions.3 min ago
Cara Zoe postedSeriously? Secret Life?3 min ago
Meg13 postedI miss girls...3 min ago
land♥n's m♥m postedwhen did you switch to size 1 diapers5 min ago
about us login register
forums tickers pregnancy strollers search
members pregnancy parenting photos & media everything else
my accountregister / loginsearchmembers mapwhos onlineadvanced search
calendar weeks 1 - 40 due date calculator top 40 books cartoons pregnancy models sarcastic journalist forums resources & links pregnancy issues due date buddies teen pregnancy baby names ttc & adoption suffering & loss abortion survivors preparing for baby labor & birth tickers pregnancy tickers
forums resources & links post partum issues parents with preemies parents with infants parents with toddlers parents with kids single parenting teen parenting special needs tickers birthday tickers
member albums family funny stuff pregnancy babies home stuff miscellaneous forums the photo spot
forumsfree for all sex & relationships debate & discuss contests & competitions creation station weight loss & fitness shopping & classifieds faqs & feedback the drama corner

About | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Advertise

All contents copyright © baby-gaga.com 2003-2009. All Rights Reserved.