Forums > Debate & DiscussPage 1 2 3 4 5by: It's been fun.

The Governor that stole Christmas.

I agree with the idea of a "holiday" tree.
I disagree. It is a Christmas tree, not a "holiday" tree.
Other.
view results

The Governor that stole Christmas.

posted 31st Oct
The Governor of Kentucky has been apparently nicknamed "the governor that stole Christmas" due to his recent decision to call the annual Christmas tree that is put up downtown a "holiday" tree in respect to people who don't celebrate Christmas.

FRANKFORT, Kentucky -- Gov. Steve Beshear has angered some Christians with his yuletide terminology.
A giant evergreen that will brighten the Capitol lawn this winter won't be called a Christmas tree. Instead, the Beshear administration has dubbed it a "holiday tree."
The Rev. Jeff Fugate, pastor of Clays Mill Baptist Church in Lexington, said Christians find the change troubling.
"If you call it a holiday tree," Fugate asked, "which holiday are you talking about? We don't put up a holiday tree for Easter or New Year's or Thanksgiving. We put a tree up for Christmas."
Beshear administration spokeswoman Cindy Lanham said the tree will be in celebration of a variety of winter holidays, including Christmas and Hanukkah.
"This is a special time of the year for many Kentuckians," she said.
The spat in Kentucky is only the latest in an ongoing Christmas debate. Some retailers, including Wal-Mart, have returned to greeting customers with "Merry Christmas" after coming under attack for directing employees to say "Happy Holidays."
In Kentucky, political foes are using the issue to bash the Democratic governor and his administration.
"Steve Beshear in his continued swing to the left shows that political correctness is more important than Kentucky values," said Republican Senate President David Williams of Burkesville. "It is difficult to see how anyone could take offense at the cherished tradition of Christmas at the Kentucky Capitol."
Beshear spokeswoman Jill Midkiff said the terminology is intended to be inclusive.

"Obviously, to Governor Beshear and the first lady, who are both Christians, it is certainly a Christmas tree," Midkiff said. "What is important is to remember what this time of year is all about — family and caring for those less fortunate."
Using the term "holiday tree" typically is intended to avoid offending people who are not Christian, said Paul Simmons, an ethics professor at the University of Louisville. And he said "holiday tree" is the more fitting description, considering the tradition started out among pagans and was later blended into the Christian celebration of Christmas.
"It really is a more generalizable symbol," Simmons said.
The Beshear administration sent out a public call on Monday for Kentuckians who think they might have the perfect "holiday tree" to consider donating it to the state. The solicitation called for a pyramid-shaped tree between 35 and 50 feet tall.
Sounds like a Christmas tree to Martin Cothran, spokesman for the Family Foundation of Kentucky.
"It's the administration that stole Christmas," Cothran said. "I think their heart is two sizes too small," he said, quoting a line from How The Grinch Stole Christmas.
Fugate said he believes the Beshear administration has caved to political pressure.
"What's bothersome about this is that it's not the majority opinion," Fugate said. "There is a groundswell of Americans who are fed up."

What do you think about his decision of a "holiday" tree? Are people overreacting? D&D.
quote
I have 1 angel baby & live in Germany
posted 31st Oct
We have aChanukahbush lol.
quote
I'm due January 6th (a girl), have 1 child & 1 angel baby & live in Arizona
posted 31st Oct
Quoting Emma♥Ethan:“ The Governor of Kentucky has been apparently nicknamed "the governor that stole Christmas" due to his ... [snip!] ... of Americans who are fed up." What do you think about his decision of a "holiday" tree? Are people overreacting? D&D.”

So what...Its fine to call it a Holiday tree. Im a Christian and I see no problem with it.
quote
I have 2 kids & live in New York
posted 31st Oct
it seriously annoys me that people allow political correctness to interfere with how life is lived .... I call the so called holiday tree at city hall the christmas tree and anyone else who calls it otherwise gets promptly corrected lol ... city hall did not steal MY christmas  



but seriously that irritates me
quote
I have 4 kids & live in Manitoba
posted 31st Oct
it seriously annoys me that people allow political correctness to interfere with how life is lived .... I call the so called holiday tree at city hall the christmas tree and anyone else who calls it otherwise gets promptly corrected lol ... city hall did not steal MY christmas  



but seriously that irritates me
quote
I have 4 kids & live in Manitoba
posted 31st Oct
It doesnt really matter one way or another to me what others call it. Personally I call it a Christmas tree
quote
I have 1 child & live in Texas
posted 31st Oct
I think that seeing as how he is talking about a tree that is going to be publically displayed on State property that people should understand that he is being "politically correct".

I could care less what anyone calls it, but politically he did the right thing.

Its the same as stores telling employees not to say "Merry Christmas" but to say "Happy Holidays" instead. Its all about the politics.
quote
I have 4 angel babies & live in Lawton, Oklahoma
posted 31st Oct
I'm kind of on the fence with this. I see both sides. If they decorate the tree to represent all winter holidays that would be cool but if they make it look like a Christmas tree they should just keep  calling it that. People take holidays way too seriosuly sometimes. Its supposed to be a time to celebrate, come together, and spend time with family. Not get mad because someone says "merry Christmas". No one ever says that to try to be rude. They are trying to be nice.
quote
I have 1 child & live in Surprise, Arizona
posted 31st Oct
Pst...... I have Corzine. I'll trade.
quote
I live in New Jersey
posted 31st Oct
Quoting Just Smiling to Smile.:“ I think that seeing as how he is talking about a tree that is going to be publically displayed on State ... [snip!] ... same as stores telling employees not to say "Merry Christmas" but to say "Happy Holidays" instead. Its all about the politics.”

 
quote
I have 2 kids & live in New York
posted 31st Oct
He did the right thing. Our Mayor's "Christmas Tree" that goes up in Kansas City has been called a "Holiday Tree" for a few years now and I don't recall anyone pitching a fit about it.

Good grief.
quote
I have 1 child & live in Missouri
posted 31st Oct
Quoting Emma♥Ethan:“ The Governor of Kentucky has been apparently nicknamed "the governor that stole Christmas" due to his ... [snip!] ... of Americans who are fed up." What do you think about his decision of a "holiday" tree? Are people overreacting? D&D.”

I'm curious, (& this may come off racist but w/e) how many people who were born in the US and who's families are from the US celebrate a holiday other then Christmas?

Because here almost everyone celebrates Christmas, and the ones who don't are Jewish, and celebrate Hanuka. But I'm not saying Real Americans celebrate Christmas, I'm just curious, because I don't know of any Canadians who don't.

I'm just curious if this could be linked back to the debate about people leaving other countries, coming to the US & Canada and changing it. Such as the national anthem in schools, as one example.
quote
I have 1 child & live in Ontario
posted 31st Oct
Quoting sratrat:“ I'm kind of on the fence with this. I see both sides. If they decorate the tree to represent all winter ... [snip!] ... Not get mad because someone says "merry Christmas". No one ever says that to try to be rude. They are trying to be nice.”

I agree with you.
quote
I have 1 angel baby & live in Germany
posted 31st Oct
Everyone calls it a Christmas Tree at home   He didn't do anything but choose a side to pander to really..
quote
I have 3 kids & 1 angel baby & live in Kuwait
posted 31st Oct
Quoting Amanda & Princess[CLD]:“ I'm curious, (& this may come off racist but w/e) how many people who were born in the US and who's ... [snip!] ... leaving other countries, coming to the US & Canada and changing it. Such as the national anthem in schools, as one example.”

Re-reading that, it is really worded poorly. My question is, is there another form of Christmas that American's celebrate? Or is it just people who come from other countries?
quote
I have 1 child & live in Ontario
nextpost reply

allsearch

topic keyword(s)


who's online

There are 212 people online90 members & 122 guestssee all 90 members
 
alllatest topics
Green Eyed Mama postedGoodbye Cruel BG world!3 min ago
Good Lawd! *FFMB* postedcome laugh with me! :D5 min ago
Samantha [*Averys Mommy*] postedSleeping16 min ago
Miss Kristin Renee! postedBaby movement23 min ago
retrobw postedI need helping sleeping, for sure.29 min ago
3 little monsters posted30,00033 min ago
Shanna (Emery's mommy) postedKicking at 23 weeks =D38 min ago
Shanna (Emery's mommy) posteddeleted41 min ago
ran! posteddoes anybody know how to....42 min ago
about us login register
forums tickers pregnancy strollers search
members pregnancy parenting photos & media everything else
my accountregister / loginsearchmembers mapwhos onlineadvanced search
calendar weeks 1 - 40 due date calculator top 40 books cartoons pregnancy models sarcastic journalist forums resources & links pregnancy issues due date buddies teen pregnancy baby names ttc & adoption suffering & loss abortion survivors preparing for baby labor & birth tickers pregnancy tickers
forums resources & links post partum issues teen parenting special needs parents with preemies parents with infants parents with toddlers parents with kids tickers birthday tickers
member albums family funny stuff pregnancy babies home stuff miscellaneous forums the photo spot
forumsfree for all sex & relationships debate & discuss contests & competitions creation station weight loss & fitness shopping & classifieds faqs & feedback the drama corner

About | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Advertise

All contents copyright © baby-gaga.com 2003-2009. All Rights Reserved.