re: Would you buy these for your Daughter...

Definitely!

As hard as it would be because after 2 boys I'm hoping my daughter will be super girly (even though I'm not), yes I would. If that's what she wanted!

I'd also buy my sons Dora or Tinkerbell etc shoes if they wanted them.

I buy DD boy clothes and shoes every now and then. More so when she was a baby. She looks amazing in blue, but there's almost nothing in blue for baby girls. Now that she's getting older, she is more into girl stuff.

Quoting Olivia Foxworth:" if she really wanted them? My kids needed new shoes, My 3 year old DD does not like girly things and ... [snip!] ... if you don't buy your kids character shoes would you buy your DD "boy shoes" from the boy section if she really wanted them?)"

Hell yeah I'd buy them! I don't really care what gender items are for... I buy what I like and the same for my daughter.

I'd throw a small party if DD wanted something that didn't have princesses smeared all over it.

If a kid wants an item of clothing, I think it's fine, regardless of whether it's a "boy" item or a "girl" item.

I want those shoes!

I think let them wear what they want to wear.
within reason of course.

I'm answering without reading three pages. I'll go back and read, and edit if I have anything else to add.

But yes, absolutely. Why shouldn't she be able to wear what's comfortable for her and what she likes? Same for my son. :shrug: It's the same with toys, and all that other jazz. My son has wanted one of those glitter wands before, he got it. My daughter plays with his action figures and stuff. She wears his hand me down clothes. I guess I just don't see an issue.

i would i have 5yr old and sees into super heros. and girly stuff to. Her fav ones are the x man. Its funny she can name every xman and even the ones thats not that popular good guys and bad ones. I dont see nothing wrong wth it..She kid

heck yes! my daughter actually prefers "boy" things and I have no problem buying them for her  

I don't have a girl but yes I would get those for a girl if she wanted them. I'd also get my boy pink shoes and a tutu if he wanted it. As long as he's gonna wear it and not make me waste the money, he can have any clothes he wants.

Sure. My daughter can wear whatever she likes. Had we had a boy, the same would go for him.