Ok, so I have had a list of names for boys and girls that I've kept (and added to) since I got my bfp with my 4 year old.

Her name is Charlotte Evelyn.

My hubby and I, initially, thought of naming our new baby Eileen Esther… but my hubby went through my name list again and his fave is Scarlett Eileen... Which I am totally in love with too- I just worry about having a Charlotte and a Scarlett. Too matchy matchy?

Yes, I think they are very matchy.

Quoting The Pretender:" Ok, so I have had a list of names for boys and girls that I've kept (and added to) since I got my bfp ... [snip!] ... Eileen... Which I am totally in love with too- I just worry about having a Charlotte and a Scarlett. Too matchy matchy?"

WAY too matchy. Although, I think Ruby and Charlotte would be cute!

Those are way too close! Don't do it, lol.

I personally love Scarlett, that would of been my youngests name if he had turned out to be a girl. But they match too close in my opinion so no I wouldnt use it!

Way too matchy IMO

Very similar. I wouldn't use it.

horribly similar. Scarlett should be taken off your list all together and never used.

Definitely too similar... Does Charlotte have a nickname though? (I hate saying don't use Scarlet, because I just love it SOOOO much.)

Yeah they really are matchey, but it's cute  

I wouldn't mind doing that with my kids.

I love it, it is matchy, but I just think it's even cuter that way lol....not much different than people starting all their kid's name with the same letter.

Way to matchy! I have a Charlotte and if I have another girl someday, I love Violet but worry it's too close. Do you use a nickname for your Charlotte? I call mine Lottie  

I usually call her "Char" or "Rotten" lol