We pay $183 per month for a 2012 Prius and a 2013 Elantra through Geico. It's all subjective to your driving record and where you live though... our insurance is stupid high because we live in DWI capitol of the smurfing planet. We all suffer for others mistakes even though both my husband and I have perfect driving records. SUCKS!
Quoting You're not my demographic:" For car insurance? How many cars? What years? And what company? ....Go!"
I pay $189 for two cars. One 2005 Ford Focus hatchback and one 2008 Dodge Avenger. Both full coverage, and that also includes my homeowner's insurance and life insurance.