Forums > Sex & RelationshipsPage 1 <> 8by: D'Aquino02

re: Boyfriend wants a Vasectomy

posted 28th Jan
Quoting LeTs*StArT*a*RiOt!:" What kind of compromise do you want when it comes to this? If he wants to do this, and she doesn't, ... [snip!] ... everyone would be telling her that it's her body, and her choice. I say the same thing. It's his body. It's his choice. "

Uh, you just gave me a perfect example of them compromising. Him deciding to harvest his sperm so that the option isn't completely ruled out.
Therefor considering her feelings, making her feel like AT LEAST having another kid was still an option.. They both win in that situation. He gets his vasectomy like he wants, her option of having kids with him isn't completely gone and when that decision comes on whether or not they want another kid they can deal with that.
quote
I live in Texas
posted 28th Jan
Quoting LeTs*StArT*a*RiOt!:" What kind of compromise do you want when it comes to this? If he wants to do this, and she doesn't, ... [snip!] ... everyone would be telling her that it's her body, and her choice. I say the same thing. It's his body. It's his choice. "


You are still taking it to an extreme situation. If he chooses to just go get a vasectomy then that is pretty much it. He can get it reversed but even that has a limit. A comprimise would be giving it time or yea her getting BC until they make a final decision. Definately shouldn't be a "I am getting it, deal" type of situation in any type of relationship, and no I fully believe that both people in a relationship decide serious matters such as this. Children, finances, if it were her who didn't want more kids and her SO did, I would tell her to consider his feelings as well. They are serious life decisions and it's selfish of him not to consider her feelings before doing so.
quote
I'm TTC since June '08, have 1 child & 5 angel babies & live in Warminster, Pennsylvania
posted 28th Jan
Quoting LeTs*StArT*a*RiOt!:" Not really. It's his body. He can do what he wants with it, and if she has that much of a problem with ... [snip!] ... and give birth because the man wants to keep his child. Why should he have to not get a vasectomy because she wants more kids?"

Ok I get your point his body his choice, but i dont see the problem in trying to see if there is a way of working some sort of agreement... I am not rushing this in any sort of way..
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Modesto, California
posted 28th Jan
Quoting J u l i a .:" Uh, you just gave me a perfect example of them compromising. Him deciding to harvest his sperm so that ... [snip!] ... with him isn't completely gone and when that decision comes on whether or not they want another kid they can deal with that. "

  Yeah, no, because he has his vasectomy NOW in the situation I was describing. They can harvest the sperm later on if he changes his mind. That's not compromise, that's a way around the situation if he were to change his mind...
quote
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Virginia
posted 28th Jan
Quoting Mamma Boo!:" Ok I get your point his body his choice, but i dont see the problem in trying to see if there is a way of working some sort of agreement... I am not rushing this in any sort of way.."


I think the only compromise (that's practical) is asking your boyfriend to hold off on a vasectomy for a while. A few months, a year, whatever...
quote
I'm due December 9th (it's a surprise), have 1 child & live in Kansas
posted 28th Jan
Quoting LeTs*StArT*a*RiOt!:"   Yeah, no, because he has his vasectomy NOW in the situation I was describing. They can harvest the ... [snip!] ... later on if he changes his mind. That's not compromise, that's a way around the situation if he were to change his mind... "

Well there are plenty of other ways to compromise on this.. Other than making a head strong decision that like I said BEFORE would not only effect HIM but her as well.
quote
I live in Texas
posted 28th Jan
Quoting BoogsMaMa:" You are still taking it to an extreme situation. If he chooses to just go get a vasectomy then that ... [snip!] ... his feelings as well. They are serious life decisions and it's selfish of him not to consider her feelings before doing so."

No, that's not pretty much it. He can harvest his sperm, he can get it reversed. Sperm still develop after a vasectomy, it doesn't affect sperm production. And it's not an extreme, it's exactly what's happening now. You think that this decision about his body should have a compromise, and he should stop and not get it done because she wants kids. Same kind of situation. And your 'compromises' are not compromising.
quote
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Virginia
posted 28th Jan
Quoting loser mom:" I think the only compromise (that's practical) is asking your boyfriend to hold off on a vasectomy for a while. A few months, a year, whatever..."
and thats all i ask of him is to hold off a lil, who knows i could change my mind and not want more kids or he can even maybe change his mind..
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Modesto, California
posted 28th Jan
Quoting Mamma Boo!:" Ok I get your point his body his choice, but i dont see the problem in trying to see if there is a way of working some sort of agreement... I am not rushing this in any sort of way.."

There are other ways to have biological children after a vasectomy. He can get it reversed or you can harvest his sperm. I still think he should get it done if he wants it done. Maybe he's had some deep thoughts about it before you got together, and this is his final decision.
quote
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Virginia
posted 28th Jan
Quoting loser mom:" I think the only compromise (that's practical) is asking your boyfriend to hold off on a vasectomy for a while. A few months, a year, whatever..."
 
quote
I live in Texas
posted 28th Jan
Quoting loser mom:" I think the only compromise (that's practical) is asking your boyfriend to hold off on a vasectomy for a while. A few months, a year, whatever..."

That's not a compromise. That's him deciding not to get it done... albeit temporarily, but still. OP, in 6 months if he still wants it and you want kids, what then?
quote
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Virginia
posted 28th Jan
Quoting LeTs*StArT*a*RiOt!:" No, that's not pretty much it. He can harvest his sperm, he can get it reversed. Sperm still develop ... [snip!] ... should stop and not get it done because she wants kids. Same kind of situation. And your 'compromises' are not compromising. "



Uhh yeah they are, compromise would be agreeing to think about it before hand. She would be on BC (preventing her from having more children which is what he wants) while they make a final decision together. I don't think that the "he doesn't want them, or his body his choice" is good enough to not consider her feelings as well as his own, plain and simple. If they can't agree after it's well thought out then thats an issue. They may not survive it as a couple, but it does not mean in anyway that her opinion shouldnt matter as much as his decision.
quote
I'm TTC since June '08, have 1 child & 5 angel babies & live in Warminster, Pennsylvania
posted 28th Jan
Quoting LeTs*StArT*a*RiOt!:" That's not a compromise. That's him deciding not to get it done... albeit temporarily, but still. OP, in 6 months if he still wants it and you want kids, what then?"

Well since he just brought the topic to my attention the other day and in 6 months he strongly still felt that way i would respect his choice on getting a vasectomy...
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Modesto, California
posted 28th Jan
Quoting Mamma Boo!:" Well since he just brought the topic to my attention the other day and in 6 months he strongly still felt that way i would respect his choice on getting a vasectomy..."

I would say that to him.
quote
I'm due September 11th (a boy), have 1 child & live in Syracuse, New York
posted 28th Jan
Quoting The Doctor:" I would say that to him."

   
quote
I'm TTC since June '08, have 1 child & 5 angel babies & live in Warminster, Pennsylvania
nextpost reply

who's online

There are 202 people online88 members & 114 guestssee all 88 members
 
alllatest topics
Allissa Specht postedIDK how he doesn't16 min ago
doors33 posted"He wants a boob."27 min ago
Draco'sStalker postedif you have 2+56 min ago
Now and Forever postedHelp me help her.1 hour ago
Mrs.Dixon1228 postedPlease Watch1 hour ago
StewedAngie postedOfficially over being pregnant1 hour ago
Allissa Specht postedWTF mother nature1 hour ago
Michael's Mommy ♥ postedPositive Discipline1 hour ago
kthx. postedA series of unfortunate events...1 hour ago
Eli's Mommy + 32wks postedMy DS 1st birthday cake!1 hour ago
RegisterLoginSearchMembers MapWhos OnlineAdvanced Search
Pregnancy Weeks 1 - 40 Due Date Calculator Top 40 Books Cartoons Pregnancy Models Sarcastic Journalist Forums Resources & Links Pregnancy Issues Due Date Buddies Teen Pregnancy Baby Names TTC & Adoption Suffering & Loss Abortion Survivors Preparing for Baby Labor & Birth Tickers Pregnancy Tickers
Parenting Months 0 - 12 Baby Models Forums Resources & Links Post Partum Issues Parents with Preemies Parents with Infants Parents with Toddlers Parents with Kids Single Parenting Teen Parenting Special Needs Tickers Birthday Tickers
Forums Free for All Photo Spot Debate & Discuss Health & Well-Being Sex & Relationships All Things Food Contests Creation Station Weight Loss & Fitness Shopping & Classifieds Faqs & Feedback The Drama Corner

About | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Advertise

All contents copyright © baby-gaga.com 2003-2011. All Rights Reserved.