Other ideas of not super, super common? (Yes, I know Caleb isn't uncommon, but I've just always loved it!)
Needs to be one or three syllables for middle. Sadly, I like a lot of other two syllable ones such as Ethan or Jephtha, but don't like how the syllables end up even then.

<blockquote><b>Quoting suzyq463:</b>" Other ideas of not super, super common? (Yes, I know Caleb isn't uncommon, but I've just always loved ... [snip!] ... Sadly, I like a lot of other two syllable ones such as Ethan or Jephtha, but don't like how the syllables end up even then."</blockquote>




I love Tobias. If DD was a boy, that'd be in the running for her name.

i voted tobiah.. i didnt see jameson i like that!

I like the way Caleb Everett sounds.

Jamieson. Mine was going to be named Jamieson is she was a boy cuz her fathers names jamie so it would be 'Jamie's son'. I think its a really cute name.

Maybe use his daddy's name or middle name? Or another family name? I had too many for my boys, so all my kids have 2 middle names! William Taylor Augustus, Levi Kyle James, Christopher Kenneth Lee, and our newest little one on the way, Moira Elizabeth Jade. I think any of these names would work well with Caleb actually! It's your baby, so it's ultimately your choice. Good luck, and feel free to use any of these names.

I love Tobias and Nathaniel! I have both a Tobias and a Nathan. I tend to call the baby tobiah more often than not.

I think Nathaniel flows the best with Caleb

Nathaniel or Alexander