Which ring?

SO and I just got engaged and he is letting me pick my ring I thought for sure I wanted the amethyst then I saw the aquamarine and couldnt decide. He wants a traditional diamond but I dont see the point on spending all of that money and I love these rings soooo much. I can't decide though HELP ME!

#1. The second looks kind of fake/cheap.

I would see what band I wanted to make sure they would be a good match first.

They are both pretty... but I think I like the blue more.

I love the blue one, which is probably the aquamarine one ahaha.! Very pretty.  

Congrats on the engagement  

I think they are both pretty, but I like the amethyst better.

I too wanted a non-diamond ring and got tanzanite for mine  

2 nd one is very pretty

Round cut sparkles more, so i'd probably go with the aquamarine haha

I am doing a thin solid white gold band, so I like the diamond accents. The amethyst represents when we met and also the month we conceived our son, so I am leaning towards that too, and the amethyst has diamonds all the way up the prongs too.

Quoting pilot Jess:" Congrats on the engagement   I think they are both pretty, but I like the amethyst better. I too wanted a non-diamond ring and got tanzanite for mine  "

Thank you, I know they are so pretty and both rings above are under 400.00 <3

I love the amethyst!!

I'd pick an aquamarine one, only because it's my birth stone (March)

Quoting FutureMRSmama:" SO and I just got engaged and he is letting me pick my ring I thought for sure I wanted the amethyst ... [snip!] ... but I dont see the point on spending all of that money and I love these rings soooo much. I can't decide though HELP ME! "

Aquamarine for sure. I love blue, and I dont like square gems.

My birthstone (Mar) is aquamarine... but idk... there's just something really beautiful and classy about that amethyst one! I like it better  

Amethyst! They're both beautiful, but my engagement ring is Amethyst.

Amethyst, since it means more to you two personally, plus it looks less cheap. I really don't like aquamarine. Couldn't imagine wearing such a bright colour every day.