Quoting Captain Obvious:" I would have done the same thing."
Quoting Faith1LovesMLP:" I would have done the same thing. I also would have told SO to shove it and kept the cat. If the neighbor asked, I'd play dumb lol"
Quoting Uncle Obama's Banana:" Lol I really want to. And I wouldn't need to play dumb either. The only way he's ever been willing to ... [snip!] ... too because other than SO I have a cat here at home who is exactly like him other than looks and I know he would be jealous "Aww. My four cats hate each other, but they don't fight anymore. Just ignore each other.