Quoting JessieLeeAnne:" Yeah, I was a little smurf in school. lol But, very true. Didnt know I would have a "gaydar" at 11 though! Crazy! "
I totally did. My brother and I had a tutor for computers skills when we were ages 8-12, who was in his late 30s. Both of us thought he was gay from day 1. Married 10+ years, had like 5 kids, uber-masculine guy, kind of a slob, so there was nothing "stereotypical" or obvious. We eventually sort of accepted that he was straight but the 'dar never stopped pinging.
Came out like 2 years ago, he's in his 50s now.