Quoting khigh:" If there isn't a II, the new baby would be a II. It's like in the British royal family. There can be a Richard I, then a Henry the I, then a Richard the II, and so on."
Quoting My boys = My life:" If there is already a II then he would be a III would he not?? Your grandfather was the first with the ... [snip!] ... would be the III would he not? This baby would be the fourth with the name? lol, Im not sure how it works so I don't know."
Quoting Snotface♫[usmc]:" No, my dad and brother are a I and II for a whole other name. My grandfather was the only one with his name and now this baby will have his exact name. "ohh. gotcha.. Then yes I would consider him a II since he is the second with that name.
Quoting I'm His Amy He's My Rory:" Just goes in order no matter the generation. Like My dad is I, brother is II, nephew is III and if I were somehow stupid enough to do the same name mine would be IV"