Forums > Debate & DiscussPage 1 2 3 4by: Hathor + A

Throwing the match for a handicapped

Fair
 
76% (25 votes)
Unfair
 
24% (8 votes)

re: Throwing the match for a handicapped

posted 5th Dec
Quoting HotMom21ERF:" why shouldnt he be? and yes, you can WANT to be treated like everyone else, but when its IMPOSSIBLE for you to do the same things physically, what are you going to do, huh?"

Not play a sport you are physically incapable of? I LOVE playing basketball, but I'm not good at it because I'm shorter than most women who play. Should I have asked other girls to go easy on me because there is no way to win?
quote
I have 1 child & live in Fort Sill, Oklahoma
posted 5th Dec
Quoting khigh:" Yep. The boy with CP wants to be treated like everyone else. He can lose like everyone else."


He would lose, no matter what. He can't move anything but his arm .....
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Massachusetts
posted 5th Dec
Quoting khigh:" Not play a sport you are physically incapable of? I LOVE playing basketball, but I'm not good at it ... [snip!] ... because I'm shorter than most women who play. Should I have asked other girls to go easy on me because there is no way to win?"
That is COMPLETELY different. He isn't shorter, or smaller, he can't move.

I can't see how anyone would think this is a bad story or unfair. The boy did a wonderful thing and by the looks of the recent interview the boy with CP was thrilled.
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Massachusetts
posted 5th Dec
Quoting khigh:" Not play a sport you are physically incapable of? I LOVE playing basketball, but I'm not good at it ... [snip!] ... because I'm shorter than most women who play. Should I have asked other girls to go easy on me because there is no way to win?"
you are ridiculous. being PHYSICALLY INCAPABLE and just sucking at a sport are two different things.
quote
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Kentucky
posted 5th Dec
Quoting BoOm French Toast:" He would lose, no matter what. He can't move anything but his arm ....."

And? If he were more worried about winning and losing than playing the sport, he wouldn't be playing.
quote
I have 1 child & live in Fort Sill, Oklahoma
posted 5th Dec
Quoting BoOm French Toast:" He would lose, no matter what. He can't move anything but his arm ....."

He is aware of this. If losing bothered him, he wouldn't be on the team.

Come on people, he is not a defenseless puppy. He is a normal, able-minded boy with physical limitations. Joining the team and competing was his choice.
quote
I have 1 angel baby & live in Kentucky
posted 5th Dec
<blockquote><b>Quoting khigh:</b>" Yep. The boy with CP wants to be treated like everyone else. He can lose like everyone else."</blockquote>


I really hope you never have a child with cp. My daughter has cp and yes we treat her like everyone else but she also gets love and support. If she wants to do something she will do it. Even if she can't physically do it we will make it happen if that's what.she wants. And that's all I am saying on this thread.
quote
I have 4 kids & live in Mississippi
posted 5th Dec
Quoting bbbt:" He is aware of this. If losing bothered him, he wouldn't be on the team. Come on people, he is not ... [snip!] ... a defenseless puppy. He is a normal, able-minded boy with physical limitations. Joining the team and competing was his choice. "
so, the other boy was supposed to just demolish him while he lay there helpless, unable to move?
quote
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Kentucky
posted 5th Dec
Quoting Captain Lauren + ?:" http://youtu.be/Ao8UbgSopD4 Thirteen-year-old Jared Stevens is just like any other kid his age, intellectually ... [snip!] ... my son One of SO's friends pointed out that it was unfair for the able bodied child to pair him with the other kid. WDYT? "

I think that they obviously talked to the other kid and he was ok with it. Why else would he throw the match? That's not unfair... that's compassion!
quote
I have 3 kids & live in Venezuela
posted 5th Dec
Quoting Juliette:" <blockquote><b>Quoting khigh:</b>" Yep. The boy with CP wants to be treated like everyone ... [snip!] ... Even if she can't physically do it we will make it happen if that's what.she wants. And that's all I am saying on this thread."

I think she has a better grasp on CP than you do, and that is unfortunate considering your daughter has it.
quote
I have 1 angel baby & live in Kentucky
posted 5th Dec
Quoting bbbt:" I think she has a better grasp on CP than you do, and that is unfortunate considering your daughter has it. "

That's smurfing rude. Seriously?
quotesmurfs?
I have 2 kids & live in Massachusetts
posted 5th Dec
Quoting bbbt:" I think she has a better grasp on CP than you do, and that is unfortunate considering your daughter has it. "
seriously, what the smurf. her daughter has CP , she lives with it everyday. im sure she has a smurfing excellent grasp on it
quotesmurfs?
I'm TTC since April '13, have 1 child & live in Kentucky
posted 5th Dec
Quoting HotMom21ERF:" so, the other boy was supposed to just demolish him while he lay there helpless, unable to move?"

Again, we need to stop with this putting kids with disabilities in a bubble. He and his parents know about potential injuries. Wrestling is a competitive sport. The boy could have pinned him down easily without hurting him, and I'm sure most boys competing against him would have. The point is to let (Jared?) participate in the sport fairly, like a completely normal child, without his disabilities lying in the forefront.
quote
I have 1 angel baby & live in Kentucky
posted 5th Dec
If the boy was emotionally and intellectually at the same age as his peers, he knows he has a severe case of CP and would have a very small chance of winning. Even giving his best shot, he knew he would still lose and if he was upset because the match was thrown the original story would have went in a different direction instead of saying how happy he was. Since hes perfectly capable of expressing his emotions.
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Indiana
posted 5th Dec
I worked with kids and adults with special needs. Each individual reacts differently, some of my clients would rather lose on their own merits than be given a win, and some appreciate feeling special for getting the cheers, even if they had help winning.

Since this boy falls into the latter category, I think it's awesome.
quote
I have 2 kids & live in Vantaa, Finland
nextpost reply

who's online

There are 333 people online142 members & 191 guestssee all 142 members
 
alllatest topics
karons postedHow To Save The Wedding Dress1 min ago
Kelly&Coralie postedI hate being anxious15 min ago
AlannahsMommy(: postedShould I worry? :/43 min ago
NikitaxLove postedWhat is generally more accurate1 hour ago
I♥RYLEIGH postedcould you1 hour ago
Elliot Reid postedOMG1 hour ago
Caimma postedDo you know what sucks?1 hour ago
chantellejade postedthe midwife.1 hour ago
Is that still my name? postedLezbo1 hour ago
RegisterLoginSearchMembers MapWhos OnlineAdvanced Search
Pregnancy Weeks 1 - 40 Due Date Calculator Top 40 Books Cartoons Pregnancy Models Sarcastic Journalist Forums Resources & Links Pregnancy Issues Due Date Buddies Teen Pregnancy Baby Names TTC & Adoption Suffering & Loss Abortion Survivors Preparing for Baby Labor & Birth Tickers Pregnancy Tickers
Parenting Months 0 - 12 Baby Models Forums Resources & Links Post Partum Issues Parents with Preemies Parents with Infants Parents with Toddlers Parents with Kids Single Parenting Teen Parenting Special Needs Tickers Birthday Tickers
Forums Free for All Photo Spot Debate & Discuss Health & Well-Being Sex & Relationships All Things Food Contests Creation Station Weight Loss & Fitness Shopping & Classifieds Faqs & Feedback The Drama Corner

About | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Advertise

All contents copyright © baby-gaga.com 2003-2011. All Rights Reserved.