Please help!

Neither. Both are overused.

Quoting Rebekah Mariah:" Please help!"

Neither are my taste at all but please do not go with Madison. There are so so many Madison's out there it's ridiculous.

Third option?

any suggestions?

i dont have a 3rd option iv had my heart set on these 2 since i can remember lol

I Love Madison ! & who cares if it popular if you love the name go for it  

if i had to have a 3rd one i would say Alana but i do not want to change the middle name im in love with it

Does very very popular names bother you? If not, I'd go with Madison

Arianna because Madison is ugly, masculine and overdone.

Neither.

Popular names dont bother me unless i know alot of people with the name. and i dont know many madison's or arianna's

What about Aria Raine instead of Ariana?

Arianna if it must be one of these two. Madison is ugly and a masculine name

Quoting Mama♥Sweetpea:" What about Aria Raine instead of Ariana?"

This. Aria is lovely.