Quoting Kelly&Coralie:" Why would it be gross? Make it a day or two in advance and serve cold It HAS to be served cold."
Quoting Ashley Jean ♥:" Definitely make it tonight. So much better cold! As if you haven't heard that from everyone else already. ... [snip!] ... lol I make cupcakes and pies for a living (cupcakery) and I always make the pumpkin pies the night before delivery. "