Which edit?

I'm getting a poll on the "matte trend" and if it works for my photography.

I like the 2nd.
But I love matte and use it on almost all of my pictures  

i like the 2nd one better

Well, darn. I like both of them. Aren't I so helpful!

First one more color. Second one you guys look faded.

Quoting ~*VINTAGE LOVE*~:" First one more color. Second one you guys look faded."

That's what 'matte' is...

Great pic.

I like the second.

Quoting ~*VINTAGE LOVE*~:" First one more color. Second one you guys look faded."

haha. That's not me. I took the picture.

Quoting ~*VINTAGE LOVE*~:" First one more color. Second one you guys look faded."

 
I like the first. the second looks dull.

I like the first one for sure. It's a lot more vibrant. The second one almost looks like it needs a "color boost" or "sharpen" edit.

<blockquote><b>Quoting Legendary Bonnie Beaver:</b>" haha. That's not me. I took the picture."</blockquote>


Lol

Which one do they prefer?

Quoting ~*VINTAGE LOVE*~:" First one more color. Second one you guys look faded."

I agree!!!!

I love sharper colors so I'm not as into the matte. It can look good sometimes but when you compare it to the other edit I don't like it as well. Almost like you can see what the picture can really be.

Quoting ~*VINTAGE LOVE*~:" <blockquote><b>Quoting Legendary Bonnie Beaver:</b>" haha. That's not me. I took the picture."</blockquote> Lol Which one do they prefer?"

haha. I just tried this one just to try it. I've already printed off the prints and everything. Just messing around.

Quoting Mandy and her girls!~:" I love sharper colors so I'm not as into the matte. It can look good sometimes but when you compare it ... [snip!] ... but when you compare it to the other edit I don't like it as well. Almost like you can see what the picture can really be."

Yea, I kinda feel like the second one is the "Before" and the first one is the "after" Rather than the other way around.