I like Lydia Sue. I really like all the first names though. Alice just doesn't sound right with Sue. Maybe it's the repetitive "s" sound.

Eliza Sue
Amelia Sue
Audrey Sue
Eleanor/Nora Sue
Natalia Sue
Josephine Sue
Maya Sue
Evangeline Sue
Lillian Sue
Lorelei Sue

Quoting Beatrix Kiddo:" I like all of your choices, but Margaret is the best IMO. I also like Dorothea "Dottie" Sue, or Matilda "Tilly" Sue."

I love Matilda. He shot it down  

Quoting Mama♥Sweetpea:" I like Lydia Sue. I really like all the first names though. Alice just doesn't sound right with Sue. ... [snip!] ... Eliza Sue Amelia Sue Audrey Sue Eleanor/Nora Sue Natalia Sue Josephine Sue Maya Sue Evangeline Sue Lillian Sue Lorelei Sue"

I agree with Alice. I adore the name, but it doesn't sound right with Sue. And I don't like Susanne, lol.

He hates all of those. He's so picky. I love Natalia, Evangeline, and Lorelai.

Quoting kthx.:" It was my grandmothers MN, who passed away in 2010. I share her MN, and I'm passing it on to my LO. So... MN is not negotiable. "

I will probably be doing the exact same thing. I have my grandmothers middle name which is Faye. I loved her dearly and she passed away in 2009. Its a nice way to honor her by passing on the family middle name.

Quoting kthx.:" I agree with Alice. I adore the name, but it doesn't sound right with Sue. And I don't like Susanne, lol. He hates all of those. He's so picky. I love Natalia, Evangeline, and Lorelai. "

My SO is picky too! It's so hard to find names that he likes  
I love Lorelei.

<blockquote><b>Quoting kthx.:</b>" I love Matilda. He shot it down  "</blockquote>



Suckage.

I didn't read though all the comments so I apologize if this was already suggested, but have you considered using Sue as a first name? Or maybe Susan or Susanna
Otherwise I like:

Rebecca Sue
Anita Sue
Ashley Sue
Audrey Sue
Barbra Sue
Brenda Sue
Bridget Sue
Deborah Sue
Ellen Sue (I also think Sue Ellen is really cute!!!)
Glenna Sue
Hayley Sue
Jamie Sue
Jenny Sue
Joanna Sue
Jody Sue
Katrina Sue
Katherine Sue
Leslie Sue
Lindsey Sue
Linda Sue
Loretta Sue ( I love this one btw)
Margaret Sue
Mariela Sue
Marina Sue
Melody Sue
Natalie Sue
Nora Sue
Rachel Sue
Tabitha Sue
Tanya Sue
Tawny Sue (Also love)
Terri Sue
Tracy Sue
Wendy Sue

I am in love with your boy name <3 No joke, I have Vincent Joseph on our boy list. I just think Vinny is so cute  

I love Margaret!

Quoting Devil Duckie:" Brandy is dated and unattractive. Sounds like a stripper from the 80's. I don't think anyone in their right mind would use Brandy these days. "

Agreed.
I was watching "A Baby Story" the other day and was shocked when I saw that the couple's 3 year old daughter was named Brandy. ICK!!

Quoting  LiveLove2012(::" I didn't read though all the comments so I apologize if this was already suggested, but have you considered ... [snip!] ... Marina Sue Melody Sue Natalie Sue Nora Sue Rachel Sue Tabitha Sue Tanya Sue Tawny Sue (Also love) Terri Sue Tracy Sue Wendy Sue"

I like Katherine... but I hate Katie, and I know that's what people would shorten it to.

I like Leslie. I'll run this by him when he gets home  

Quoting lauren♥:" I am in love with your boy name <3 No joke, I have Vincent Joseph on our boy list. I just think Vinny is so cute   I love Margaret! "

I hate Vinny as a nickname... smurfing Jersey Shore   I'd want Vince as a NN, but I know it'll be Vinny.

Sigh  

Quoting kthx.:" I like Katherine... but I hate Katie, and I know that's what people would shorten it to. I like Leslie. I'll run this by him when he gets home  "

Lol they could call her Kat or Katty if that's what you bring her up calling her and she likes it. But that's a big IF. I seriously just went through one section of my baby book and grabbed anything I thought sounded good with Sue (and not I have the name Loretta stuck in my head...and on my name list  ) If you want more let me know...I have like 10 sections left. I could probably find a few more lol.

Quoting kthx.:" I like Katherine... but I hate Katie, and I know that's what people would shorten it to. I like Leslie. I'll run this by him when he gets home  "

How about Kate for a nickname?

<blockquote><b>Quoting Back to Noob Status:</b>" How about Kate for a nickname?"</blockquote>




I looove Cate/Catherine.

Alice is my favorite, but not with the middle name. I agree that Susan or Susanna would make things flow better, but Sue is just fine, too.

I LOVE Victoria, one of my all time favorites. Lydia and Margaret are wonderful, too - I tnk Margaret is the least common of the choices of that bothers you.