The Historical Existence of Christ - Does it Matter?

account removed
posted 12th Apr '12
I recently got into a lengthy debate with a theology major friend who is a devout Pentecostal Christian. I asked him if he had researched the actual existence of Christ outside of the Bible, since little to no text from that time period makes mention of Christ as a historical man (one would think he might be kinda popular in those parts, eh?) He mentioned a Roman Census that proved Jesus Christ's human existence & also referenced another text whose author's name I'm blanking on, but those were the only two references he could think of that would prove Christ was a real man. So I started looking up this census to see if it held any water and came across this article. D&D:

-Does Christ's historical existence have any context in how you feel as a Christian? Because Christianity is based on the fundamental idea that Christ sacrificed his human body for all mankind, would it make you feel differently if it was proven that he never existed? (Which is probably impossible to disprove, but to me it just seems like it would be more important to prove it before someone decided to become a Christian. just my opinion!)

Here's the article for further reading, which leans towards the idea that Christ's existence can't be proven through the census records, because they no longer (or never did) exist: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2001/what-did-the-census-at-the-time-of-the-birth-of-christ-accomplish
quote
I have 1 child & live in Tennessee
posted 12th Apr '12
In my opion there are billions of people never mentioned in history. I don't need proof to know that people lived.
As far as how it effects my beliefs. I believe in faith through grace. Its something my heart tells me is true and I must believe for my own mental health.
I need hope to not be depressed. I have hope in a Savior.
Ignorant? Maybe/Probably. Good enough for me? Definatly!
quote
posted 12th Apr '12
I think that he existed. I don't believe that he was the son of God, just a man. His existence being proven or disproven would make no difference to me.
quote
I have 4 kids & live in New York
posted 12th Apr '12
I believe that Jesus Christ really existed because of my faith, but even then, just because he existed doesn't mean that he was necessarily the Messiah. He could have just been a great man with good philosophies. I leave it all to faith to believe in something that you honestly have no physical evidence of.
quote
I have 1 child & live in Ohio
posted 12th Apr '12
Quoting One Lazy Bitch:" I believe that Jesus Christ really existed because of my faith, but even then, just because he existed ... [snip!] ... man with good philosophies. I leave it all to faith to believe in something that you honestly have no physical evidence of."

I think that is how most religion is which probably answers your question OP. I don't think it would matter because religion is already based on faith in something you can't see or prove.
quote
I have 4 kids & live in New York
posted 12th Apr '12
christianity seems pretty made up and arbitrary to me. i dont suppose whether christ really existed changes anything.
quote
I live in Wisconsin
post reply

who's online

There are 344 people online148 members & 196 guestssee all 148 members
 
alllatest topics
AshUHHleeee postedBreastfeeding question!!1 min ago
Rebekah Garden x3 postedPotty training underwear3 min ago
A Beautiful Disaster postedchild support question6 min ago
MunchkinWrangler postedHelp with my 5yo17 min ago
Mommy 2 Kaitlyn posted9dpo & a BFN...18 min ago
MunchkinWrangler postedSex Troubles.45 min ago
Kansas Bonanno postedi feel like47 min ago
FarminMomma postedPOAS?51 min ago
Y O . M A M A postedOpinions / Advice :-) ** POLL **57 min ago
Emotional Squeekerz postedWhat's wrong with AF?1 hour ago
RegisterLoginSearchMembers MapWhos OnlineAdvanced Search
Pregnancy Weeks 1 - 40 Due Date Calculator Top 40 Books Cartoons Pregnancy Models Sarcastic Journalist Forums Resources & Links Pregnancy Issues Due Date Buddies Teen Pregnancy Baby Names TTC & Adoption Suffering & Loss Abortion Survivors Preparing for Baby Labor & Birth Tickers Pregnancy Tickers
Parenting Months 0 - 12 Baby Models Forums Resources & Links Post Partum Issues Parents with Preemies Parents with Infants Parents with Toddlers Parents with Kids Single Parenting Teen Parenting Special Needs Tickers Birthday Tickers
Forums Free for All Photo Spot Debate & Discuss Health & Well-Being Sex & Relationships All Things Food Contests Creation Station Weight Loss & Fitness Shopping & Classifieds Faqs & Feedback The Drama Corner

About | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Advertise

All contents copyright © baby-gaga.com 2003-2011. All Rights Reserved.